Self-Denial: After looking a few days ago at George Whitefield’s sermon on self-denial, I thought it might be interesting to see whether John Wesley had addressed the same subject. He did, and quite directly, in a sermon preached in 1755 entitled Self-Denial. What makes the comparison especially interesting is that Whitefield and Wesley stood almost at opposite poles on the doctrine of salvation. Their disagreements over grace, election, free will, and the nature of salvation were substantial and well known. Yet when both men turn to the subject of self-denial, the practical Christianity they describe begins to show some striking similarities.
The similarity becomes clearer almost immediately. Whitefield calls self-denial “the grand secret of our holy religion” and holds up the saints as examples of the self-denying life believers ought to imitate. Wesley goes even further, describing self-denial as “absolutely, indispensably necessary” to becoming and continuing Christ’s disciple. What is especially interesting is that he is fully aware that such language may sound like “salvation by works” or “establishing our own righteousness,” yet rather than backing away from the charge, he turns it against those who make it.
Wesley is plain about those whom he has in mind. He takes aim at those who emphasized sovereign grace and predestination, who objected that this kind of emphasis upon self-denial tended toward “salvation by works” or the establishment of our own righteousness. He places those objections alongside charges of “legality” and “preaching the law.” That makes the comparison with Whitefield all the more interesting, because despite their sharp differences on salvation, their practical emphasis on self-denial begins to sound surprisingly similar.
I think that is where the real issue begins. No one needs to deny that our Lord spoke of denying ourselves, taking up the cross, and following Him. But there is a great difference between understanding that language as part of what it means to follow Christ and turning it into the mechanism by which our standing as disciples is established or preserved. At that point self-denial is no longer merely descriptive. It begins to function conditionally, and the believer is left looking increasingly at his own performance to determine whether he truly belongs to Christ.
Wesley’s own definition shows just how far this reaches. Self-denial, in his treatment, means refusing our own will whenever it stands opposed to the will of God. Since the will of God is to be the supreme rule of life, Wesley says we are “not to do our own will in anything.” There is at least a little irony in hearing that from a man who defended human free will so vigorously against the Calvinists. Apparently the will must be free before conversion, only to become something we are repeatedly told not to follow afterward.
But beyond that observation, notice how expansive the definition has become. Self-denial is no longer simply connected with suffering, sacrifice, or the cost of following Christ. It now reaches into virtually every movement of the believer’s will. The emphasis shifts from following a rejected Christ to the constant suppression of our own desires, inclinations, and choices. That is a much broader doctrine than the words themselves seem to require.
There is another distinction worth making here. Christ did not say, “deny yourself things.” He said, “let him deny himself.” Those are not the same thing. Yet much of what passes for self-denial in preaching quickly becomes an inventory of things: give up this comfort, surrender that pleasure, discipline this appetite, sacrifice that preference, relinquish this possession. Before long, self-denial can become less about following Christ and more about measuring how little of life we permit ourselves to enjoy.
And that immediately creates another problem: the whole thing becomes remarkably subjective. How much is enough? Is the believer driving an older car somehow more self-denying than the one driving a newer one? Is the man with one house more consecrated than the man with three? How much comfort is too much comfort? How many possessions are too many possessions? Once self-denial is reduced primarily to the renunciation of things, the conscience is left wandering through an endless maze with no clear stopping point.
But the language of Christ is larger than that. “Whosoever will come after me, let him deny himself, and take up his cross, and follow me.” Mark 8:34. He has just announced that the Son of man “must suffer many things, and be rejected… and be killed.” Mark 8:31. Peter objects to that very idea and is rebuked because he savours “not the things that be of God, but the things that be of men.” Mark 8:33. Christ announces His cross, and then speaks of theirs.
That context seems to move us beyond ordinary religious austerity. Peter must relinquish his own conception of what following Christ and His kingdom should look like. Peter wants Christ without rejection, the kingdom without suffering, glory without shame. To deny himself, then, is not merely to give up certain pleasures. At the very least, it means abandoning the insistence that Christ and His kingdom must conform to his own expectations.
And perhaps that is where the language becomes most searching. Self-denial is not merely the refusal of certain pleasures or comforts. It is the surrender of self as the one who sets the terms – my wisdom, my righteousness, my judgment, my strength, my expectations of how God should work, my assumption that following Christ should preserve my safety, and my confidence that I can somehow make myself acceptable before God, &c. That does not exhaust everything Christ means by taking up the cross, but it brings us much closer to something deeper than a program of religious deprivation.
The same is true of taking up the cross. The cross was not a symbol for ordinary inconvenience, personal disappointment, or the various frustrations of life. It was an instrument of shame, rejection, and death. To take up the cross was to identify with a Christ whom the world had rejected and to accept whatever consequences might accompany that identification. That could mean loss, opposition, suffering, and even death, but the emphasis remains upon following Him. The cross is not something we manufacture in order to prove our devotion; it is what may come with belonging openly to a rejected Christ.
There is also a broader gospel truth that seems impossible to miss. The deepest thing a sinner must abandon is not ultimately a possession, a comfort, or an ambition, but confidence in himself. Paul speaks of counting all things loss that he might “be found in him, not having mine own righteousness.” Philippians 3:9. That is not a direct explanation of Mark 8, but it does remind us that the gospel continually moves us away from self as the ground of our hope. The great denial is not simply of things, but of ourselves as sufficient, righteous, wise, or able to stand before God apart from Christ.
That is what makes the comparison between Whitefield and Wesley so instructive. They begin from very different systems of salvation, yet both can end up placing enormous emphasis upon the believer’s own consecration. The theological structures differ, but the practical effect can begin to look surprisingly similar: attention is drawn increasingly toward the measure of our own self-denial rather than toward the sufficiency of Christ.
The point is not that self-denial has no place in the Christian life. Christ’s own words will not allow us to say that. But self-denial is not a ladder by which we climb toward Christ, nor a condition by which we keep ourselves in Him. It is the posture of those who have been brought away from confidence in themselves to follow Christ wherever He leads. We are not called to become preoccupied with the measure of our own surrender. We are called to follow Christ. MPJ
PostScript: I agree. There plainly are things we may need to deny ourselves – sinful appetites, pleasures, opportunities, even legitimate things when they begin to govern us or conflict with faithfulness to Christ. I certainly did not mean to deny that. My thoughts were more with making those individual acts of denial the definition or measure of the Christian life itself. Once we do that, the whole thing becomes terribly subjective: how much denial is enough, and who decides? As for Piper’s “Christian Hedonism,” I can see the point he is trying to make. In one sense, everyone pursues what he believes will bring the greatest good or happiness, and even acts of self-denial can be undertaken with some greater joy in view. Christianity is certainly not meant to be a religion of grim deprivation. My hesitation is that joy itself can begin to sound like another requirement to measure inwardly. Is my joy strong enough? Joy seems to me much more like something that arises from knowing Christ than a spiritual state we successfully work ourselves into. Joy has its place, certainly. But once it becomes another standard by which we measure the reality of our life in Christ, I think we may have shifted the attention.
Postscript: “What Whitefield and Wesley both propose is a works salvation. That is why many Calvinists are really Arminians at heart.” Oh come on: “many Calvinists are really Arminians at heart”? That’s a little rough, don’t you think? Then again, what you’re saying becomes pretty obvious, no matter how much they attempt to hide behind the doctrines of grace. A man can speak beautifully about sovereign grace and then preach the Christian life almost mechanically, as though everything finally depends upon the believer’s degree of surrender, consecration, mortification, self-denial, and perseverance. The theology may remain Calvinistic on paper while the practical burden falls right back upon the creature. That was one of the striking things about comparing Whitefield and Wesley. They begin miles apart doctrinally, yet can leave the believer asking the same question: “Have I denied myself enough?” And if that’s where our hope rests, we’re sort of doomed, because let’s be honest – there will always be more we could have surrendered, more we could have denied, and more faithfully we could have walked. That road never really ends.